ELF Ultra Precise Brow Pencil – ABH Brow Wiz Dupe?!

I am a really big fan of ELF, and I’ve amassed quite the collection of their products since they launched in the UK but I’ve never really delved into their eyebrow collection which needed remedying so I bought the ELF Ultra Precise Brow Pencil as part of my most recent haul from the ELF UK website. Here in the UK we can now purchase ELF in larger Superdrug stores, on the Superdrug website and the ELF UK website which is amazing. The newest ELF launches can be found on the ELF UK website, as it takes a few months for them to filter through to Superdrug. The ELF Ultra Precise Brow Pencil is £6 which might sound pricey for a drugstore brow product but I’ve been looking for a dupe of the Anastasia Beverly Hills Brow Wiz ever since the price jumped up to a massive £22.

ELF Ultra Precise Brow Pencil in Neutral Brown Review and Swatches

The Anastasia Beverly Hills Brow Wiz is £22 and contains 0.08g of product whilst the ELF Ultra Precise Brow Pencil is £6 and contains 0.05g, so you do get more product in the Brow Wiz. The Brow Wiz is available in a total of ten shades whilst the ELF Ultra Precise Brow Pencil only has three shades which is very limited, but it’s still a new launch so I really hope they extend the shade range soon as three shades just isn’t enough. I’ve seen the ELF Instant Lift Brow Pencil feature in many US YouTuber beauty favourites so I also bought that one too, but it was the Ultra Precise Brow Pencil I wanted to try first as it looked so similar to the Brow Wiz and I was really intrigued to see if it was in fact a dupe.

ELF Ultra Precise Brow Pencil in Neutral Brown Review and Swatches ELF Ultra Precise Brow Pencil in Neutral Brown Review and Swatches

Our Ultra Precise Brow Pencil keeps brows in check with a super precise tip that creates a full, natural finish. On one side, the micro-slim liner defines and fills in gaps that mimic the look of real hair. On the other, the brush tames and combs brows to create effortlessly defined eyebrows.

ELF Ultra Precise Brow Pencil in Neutral Brown Review and Swatches

From the three shades on offer, I opted for Neutral Brown but the other two shades are Taupe and Brunette. The pencil has a spoolie on one end, and a retractable very fine pencil on the other. I really like the MAC Eye Brows eyebrow pencil but you can’t wind it down which drives me mad, so I like that you can wind this pencil up and down. If you were looking at these swatches, you’d think that there were two shades of pencil but it’s just one which is really strange. When I do small, gentle strokes with the pencil the colour is a cooler toned dark brown but when I press the pencil harder the colour becomes a lot warmer. I have no idea what kind of sorcery is going on with this brow pencil, but I guess it’s handy if you like to change up the tone of your eyebrows.

The pencil is nice and firm, but it’s soft enough that you don’t have to press too hard and the pencil doesn’t crumble on contact with the skin. I love that the pencil can create really fine, hair-like strokes as I don’t need a lot of filling in for my brows as they’re naturally quite full but the pencil works well at helping to define the shape. I honestly believe this pencil is just as good as the Brow Wiz and it’s £16 cheaper. The only thing that lets it down is the restrictive shade range so I’d really recommend giving it a try if you can find a shade which works for you as it’s a really great brow pencil.

Have you tried any of the ELF brow range before?


*Products featured on Gemma Etc. are press samples or gifted items unless otherwise indicated - please see my Disclaimer page for further information. This post may contain affiliated links.