Skip to Content

Acrylic vs Press on Nails – Which Is Best?

Are you trying to decide which type of nail style looks best and lasts longer? Acrylics and press on nails are both popular options, but they each have their pros and cons.

I’m going to share a comparison of acrylic vs press on nails, so you know which is better for your nails press-on nails and acrylic nails, and will give you the best results.

Acrylic vs Press on Nails - Which Is Best?

What Are Acrylic Nails?

Acrylic nails are essentially fake nails that are applied over your natural ones, usually by a nail tech. They’re created by mixing a liquid monomer and a powder polymer to form a hard protective layer that’s super strong and durable.

What’s great about them is you can shape and design them any way you want, giving you endless possibilities for creativity.

As well as making your hands look pretty, they also serve a practical purpose. If you have weak or brittle nails, acrylics will provide the strength needed to prevent breakage or splitting when applied onto your nail.

Plus, if you’re trying to grow out your natural nails, these fakes act as a protective shield while helping mask any imperfections.

Another fantastic perk of having acrylics is their long-lasting nature. With proper care and regular fills every two to three weeks, they can last up to a month without chipping or peeling, giving you long-lasting pretty nails. 

What Are The Benefits Of Acrylic Nails?

They offer long-lasting wear and are easy to maintain, so you don’t have to worry about them popping off.

Plus, with endless designs and colors to choose from, you can let your natural nails grow underneath while expressing your unique style.

Long Lasting Wear

They’re incredibly durable, providing you weeks of flawless, chip-free wear.

One of the most appealing benefits of acrylic nails is their long-lasting wear. They don’t need to be topped up with nail glue as the weeks go by, and whilst you will notice regrowth after a week or so, they are still incredibly long lasting. 

Ease Of Maintenance

With acrylic nails, the ease of maintenance is one of their biggest benefits. Unlike regular manicures that may chip or peel after just a few days, acrylic nails require less frequent touch-ups.

The secret behind this low maintenance beauty solution is in the material itself – an acrylic resin which forms a hard and durable surface on your nails.

It stands up well to daily wear and tear and can withstand much more than natural nails or other types of artificial nails can handle.

No Worry Of Them Popping Off

With fake tips, there’s no need to fret about them suddenly coming loose or falling off. One of the key benefits of acrylic nails is their resilience and durability.

They provide a sturdy, long-lasting solution that you can rely on. No worry of them popping off at inopportune times.

Acrylic nails are created using a mix of liquid and powder which hardens to form a protective layer over your natural nail.

This makes them less likely to chip or break compared to natural nails. It means you can go about your day with confidence, knowing your manicure will stay intact.

Endless Designs And Colors To Choose From

Acrylic nails offer you the luxury of choosing from a vast array of nail art. You’re not just limited to solid colors, but you can also pick from an extensive variety of designs.

Here are some popular options:

Design Description
Glitter Add some sparkle with mixed-in glitter.
Marble Effect Achieve a unique look with swirling pigment.
Ombre Blend two colors for a gradient effect.
Rhinestones Add shiny stones for an extra pop.

Natural Nails Can Grow Underneath

When you opt for acrylic nails, your natural nails can grow underneath without any hindrance.

This is a significant advantage if you’re trying to grow out short or damaged nails. Acrylic nails provide a protective shield, which helps prevent nail damage that might occur from daily activities or accidents.

This means that while you’re wearing your acrylic nail designs and vibrant colors on your acrylics, your own natural nails are growing beneath them.

Remember though, proper maintenance and regular fills are necessary to keep the acrylics looking great and ensuring your real nails stay healthy underneath it all.

What Are The Downsides Of Acrylic Nails?

What Are The Downsides Of Acrylic Nails?

While acrylic nails might seem like the perfect solution to achieving long, glamorous nails, they do come with a few downsides.

First off, you need to be prepared for the expensive upfront costs that often accompany this beauty treatment.

Over time, your natural nails can weaken and become brittle due to regular application and maintenance of acrylics.

Lastly, don’t expect a quick process; applying these artificial beauties takes time and precision for the best results.

Expensive Upfront

The upfront cost of acrylic nails can be a bit steep, but consider the long-term benefits: they’re incredibly durable, require less frequent touch-ups, and they allow you to experiment with various styles without damaging your natural nails.

To better understand why investing in acrylic nails might be worth it for you, let’s look at a comparison between them and other manicure types:

  Acrylic Nails Regular Manicure Gel Manicure
Durability High Low Medium
Upfront Cost High Low Medium
Maintenance Frequency Low High Medium
Style Versatility High Low Medium

Can Weaken Natural Nails Over Time

Over time, your natural nails can become weak and brittle due to the long-term use of these artificial enhancements. Indeed, one downside to the benefits of acrylic nails is that they can weaken natural nails over time.

Here are a few reasons why this happens:

  1. Acrylic nails often require harsh chemicals for application and removal. These chemicals can strip the natural oils from your nails, leaving them dry and fragile.
  2. The pressure exerted by acrylics on your nail beds may lead to thinning of your real nails.
  3. Frequent refills or replacements without giving your natural nails a break can cause them to become stressed and weakened.

Not Quick To Apply

With acrylic nails, if you don’t know how to apply them yourself, you’re going to have to spend a good hour or so in a nail salon, having them applied by professional nail technicians. 

With stick-on nails, you can do them yourself with a tube of nail glue. So, if you’re short on time, the fact acrylic nails aren’t quick and easy to apply, might be a downside for you.

What Are Press On Nails?

These are artificial nails that come in different shapes, sizes, and designs you can easily stick onto your natural nails for a stunning manicure in minutes.

They’re amazing because they provide an instant glam-up without the need to wait or spend much. You just apply press on nails directly; it’s as simple as that.

Pros of Press-On Nails Cons of Press-On Nails Tips for Using Press-On Nails
Easy to use and remove May not last as long as acrylics Ensure your natural nails are clean before application
Comes in various shapes, sizes, and designs Can damage natural nails if removed improperly Use quality press on nails for best results
No drying time needed Limited customization options compared to salon services Keep a nail file handy for quick adjustments

What Are The Benefits Of Press On Nails?

What Are The Benefits Of Press On Nails?

You’ll love the ease and convenience of press-on nails. They’re simple to apply and incredibly cost-effective. Plus, they can be removed effortlessly without any professional assistance.

Easy To Apply

Imagine the ease and convenience when you can apply acrylic nails right at home, saving you time and energy for other pursuits.

The application process of acrylics is pretty straightforward, making them easy to apply even if you’re a beginner.

Acrylic nails are a great option if you love having polished, professional-looking nails but don’t have the time or patience to maintain them regularly.

You just need to follow some simple steps, and you’ve got yourself a set of stunning nails.

Affordable Cost

Acrylic nails come with an affordable cost that can fit into many budgets. Unlike other nail enhancement options, acrylics won’t break your bank.

Sure, a salon manicure can be pricey, but the long-lasting results of acrylic nails make them worth every penny.

You don’t always have to go for a salon manicure to enjoy these benefits. With some practice and the right tools, you can apply and maintain your acrylic nails at home.

This DIY approach further reduces costs while still giving you the polished look you desire.

Easily Removed Without Professional Help

Having a glamorous set of talons doesn’t mean you’re stuck with them forever, darling. Removing them can be as simple as a DIY project at home – no need for costly nail salon visits or professional help.

Yes, acrylic nails are easily applied at home and similarly, they can also be removed without any professional intervention.

Soak each nail in acetone using cotton balls and wrap with foil. After about 20 minutes or so, the acrylic should be softened enough to gently scrape off.

What Are The Downsides Of Press On Nails?

While you may love the convenience and affordability of press-on nails, it’s also important to consider the potential downsides.

Have An Artificial Look

Some people don’t like how ‘fake’ press-on nails can look. They’re usually very shiny and obvious that they’re fake, as you can see the ridge of the edges on the nails, which isn’t something you have to worry about acrylic nails, as they’re moulded to your natural nails. 

Easily Pop Off

Press-on nails are stuck on with nail glue, or nail stickers, and this means, they’re more likely to pop off your natural nails.

Especially if you wash your hands frequently, as the moisture will eventually loosen the adhesive holding the false nails to your natural nails.

Can Be Hard To Find The Perfect Fit For Each Nail

When you buy a box of press-on nails, you usually get a variety of shapes and sizes.

Obviously, everybody’s hand and nails are different shapes, so you might struggle to get a decent fit with the nails included within the box. If you don’t get a perfect match, you’ll be more likely to have the nails come off quicker.

Acrylic vs Press on Nails – What Are The Main Differences?

When considering press on nails vs acrylic, several factors come into play.

Acrylic nails require more time and effort to apply since a trained professional must sculpt them onto your natural nails using liquid monomer and powder polymer.

On the contrary, press-on nails are self-adhesive and can be applied quickly without any special training or tools.

Acrylics tend to last longer – up to three weeks with proper care – while most press-ons will only stay intact for about one week.

The cost factor also sets them apart. Press-on nails are generally less expensive than acrylics, making them an economical option if you change your style frequently.

How Long Do Acrylic Nails Typically Last?

Press On Nails Vs Acrylic Nails – Which Nails Are Better For Not Causing Nail Damage?

When considering the health of your nails, press-ons take the lead as they spare you from prolonged exposure to harsh chemicals and potential damage caused by filing during acrylic application.

This makes the debate of press-on nails vs acrylic nails lean heavily towards a more protective approach.

Here are some significant points to keep in mind:

  • Press-on nails can be easily removed without damaging your natural nails.
  • They don’t require any filling or buffing, meaning less risk of damaging your nail bed.
  • Unlike acrylics, reusable press-ons save you money in the long run.
  • The application process is simple and quick, saving time compared to getting acrylics done.

While it’s true that acrylic nails may offer a longer lifespan and often appear more ‘professional’, these benefits come at a cost.

Long-term use can lead to weakened natural nails underneath due to constant pressure and lack of air circulation.

So, while both types have their pros and cons, if avoiding harm to your natural nails is a priority for you, opting for press-on could be a smart choice. 

How Long Do Acrylic Nails Typically Last?

Acrylic nails and gel nails can typically last for about two to three weeks, but it’s essential that you’re maintaining them properly.

Regular fills every two weeks are recommended to keep them looking fresh and intact. If you notice any lifting or damage, visit your nail technician to repair it promptly.

Remember, the longevity of your acrylics also depends on how fast your natural nails grow underneath. 

Are There Any Specific Care Instructions for Maintaining Acrylic Nails?

You should avoid using them as tools to prevent breakage or lifting.

Regularly apply cuticle oil to keep your nails hydrated. Avoid prolonged exposure to water and wear gloves when doing chores.

Lastly, don’t skip your nail technician’s appointments because routine fills and repairs will help maintain the health and longevity of your acrylics, and you won’t have to worry about applying nail polish either.

Can I Perform Everyday Tasks without Damaging My Acrylic Nails?

You can perform everyday tasks without damaging your acrylic nails. They’re designed to be hardy and durable.

However, it’s important to use caution while doing activities that could potentially cause harm. Avoid using them as tools or biting on them as this can lead to breakage or lifting.

With the right care, your acrylic nails should withstand daily routines with no problem at all.


What Is the Process of Removing Acrylic Nails?

To remove your acrylic nails, start by clipping them down as short as possible. Then, file away the top layer of each nail to break through the sealant.

After that, apply petroleum jelly around your skin and soak your nails in acetone for about 40 minutes. Use a wooden stick to gently push off the loosened acrylic nail.

If there’s any residue left, buff it off with a nail buffer and hydrate your hands with lotion afterward.


To sum up, acrylic nails and press on nails are both popular options when it comes to nail styling.

Acrylics offer long-lasting wear, endless designs and colors to choose from, and natural nails can grow underneath. On the other hand, press-ons are convenient to use and come at an affordable cost.

When considering damage to your natural nails though, press-ons tend to be safer since they don’t require filing or buffing during application. 

All products featured on Gemma Etc. are PR samples or gifted items, unless otherwise indicated. This post may contain affiliate links. If you wish to find out more, please see my Disclaimer within my navigation bar.